It’s been a while since we looked at a Hag, hasn’t it? The Arch-Hag was a manipulative, devious, and wily antagonist who probably knew everything your Players were going to do before they knew to do it. Night Hags are significantly less powerful creatures—CR 5 to the Arch-Hag’s CR 21—so if you’re looking to get your Party entangled in some fiendish schemes based on avarice and hate, this is the one to go with. And despite the difference in Challenge Ratings, there is still a lot of harm that this Hag can do.
According to the Monster Manual, “Night hags seek mortals to torment and turn to evil.” These are creatures that revel in corruption and manipulation in order to bring the good low. They are fey-turned-fiend themselves, and perhaps want to see others share in how they have descended into sin and degradation.

The Arch-Hag manipulates people because she wants to gain something. Power, influence, control, whatever serves her purposes. The Night Hag, however, wants to prove something.
She wants to prove that goodness is conditional. Virtue is temporary. And decency is just an act that we put on because it’s convenient.
With that in mind, a Night Hag can very easily become the driving force of an entire campaign.
Your Party is in a small village, looking for a chance to rest and recuperate between adventures. While they’re having a meal in the tavern, they hear an unsettling rumor. One of the local Pillars of Society—a schoolteacher, perhaps—has been acting strangely of late. They’re no longer the cheerful and reliable citizen that everyone has come to know and love, but rather they are dark and strange. They mutter as others pass, they look at people with ill intent, and have turned suspicious and spiteful.
You see, every night, the schoolteacher has dreamed of something terrible. They have dreamed of one of their students dying. The same child, every night, in different terrible ways. And the Night Hag tells them that the dreams can stop if they do one very simple thing: accuse that child’s father of a crime he didn’t commit.
It’s one simple lie that destroys a life and divides a town and, for a while, the schoolteacher can sleep again. But not for long, of course. The Hag has her claws in them and brings the dreams back and asks for another little, tiny misdeed. And because doing the wrong thing brings the kind of relief that doing the right thing won’t, the teacher does it again. And again.
You can decide what the Night Hag wants from all this. Does she want to destroy this town? Turn the schoolteacher permanently cruel? Does she want someone to willingly embrace evil, not just turn to it as a form of relief? Perhaps when the teacher is finally confronted and they say, “Anyone would have done it,” then that is the Hag’s victory right there.
Or, even worse: she torments her victim to the point where they beg her to do it to someone else, if only to stop their own suffering.
“Do it to Julia!” as it were.
The Night Hag has some excellent abilities that allow her to twist the minds of her victims, not the least of which is the Nightmare Haunting. She can use the Dream spell to invade a person’s unconscious and deliver torments while they sleep. She can Shape-Shift to disguise herself and gain access to her target through her talents at deception and insight. And if she has a Coven, she gains access to even more powers, mostly divinatory in nature, which means that the Night Hag can know pretty much anything she needs to as she plots this poor person’s destruction.
Which includes, in all likelihood, the arrival of your Party.
As with most Hags, you can make it nigh-impossible to surprise a Night Hag, especially one whose Coven has entrenched itself in a population center. She should know anyone who is even considering interfering with her work, and be prepared to either destroy or corrupt them as well. Fighting against a Night Hag is going to be hard. Not because she’s a powerful combatant, but because she has already claimed the battlefield for her own, and will have no problems with putting innocent people between herself and your Party.

As a DM, this means you get to be ruthless. If you’ve ever wanted to hold an entire town hostage to malevolent forces, now’s your chance. Because let’s face it—the Hag isn’t going to corrupt just anyone. They’re going to take on a keystone citizen whose downfall will drag everyone else with them. Suspicion, fear, and jealousy can spread through a town very quickly, and she will gleefully help it run its course.
And the best thing is that it takes very little real magic for her to accomplish this. All she needs is to nudge a few people in the right direction and the rest will take care of itself. By the time your Players get involved, the town should already be on its way to collapse. The citizens will have turned on each other and be more than happy to turn on your Players, perhaps deciding that they are the ones who ruined everything.
The true danger of the Night Hag depends, of course, on the scale of her corruption. If she’s got her hooks in a local alderman, that’s one thing. But if she’s been visiting the dreams of a Queen? Haunting a High Priest or a great General? Well, with those people under her crooked thumb, your adventure is no longer about helping a few hapless villagers, but about saving a civilization from devouring itself.
The truth that drives a Night Hag is simple and alluring: If you push someone hard enough, they will break. And when they do, they will break everyone around them. It’s the philosophy of The Joker: Good people aren’t really good—they just haven’t been broken yet.
In fact, when your Players finally confront the Hag, she will merely smile. Okay, they’ve got her. Now what? Will your Players expose the crimes, knowing that the truth might tear the community apart? Conceal the crimes and become implicated in them? Even if they kill the Hag, the terrible things the citizens did don’t just… undo themselves. The Hag can lose the fight but still win the argument that she believes in: people will, if given the chance, do terrible things of their own free will.
They just aren’t worth saving.
What you have to decide is if this is true of your world. Are the Hags a corrupting influence that is pulling everyone down to their level, or are they simply revealing people for who they are deep down inside? I can’t tell you which one to pick, and you certainly don’t have to agree with your Hag, but I can tell you that your choice will influence everything else about your Campaign. Even after the Night Hag is defeated, will your Players be able to trust an NPC again? Will they be able to look at power structures and authorities the same way?
How much of your Players’ optimism and innocence are you willing to trade away for an exciting D&D session?